Important Controls For Your Flow Cytometry Lab

No researcher wants to discover that the results of a long, careful experiment are confounded by an uncontrolled variable. To assist in data interpretation, you must build careful controls into your experimental workflow. These controls minimize the effects of confounding variables in the experiment while helping to identify the changes related to the independent variable. When designing a flow cytometry experiment, what controls should you consider? Below are a few experimental controls that can dramatically enhance reproducibility in your flow cytometry experiments.

Compensation

Addressing fluorescence compensation is not possible without proper controls, so it is critical to prepare controls of high quality. Compensation is a consequence of spectral overlap, which occurs because the emission spectra of fluorochromes is broader than the standard filters used to measure the specific (or major) emission.  This leads to the detection of the fluorochrome in secondary channels. 

The more colors measured within a single experiment, the more crowded the spectrum becomes, and this affects the sensitivity of your measurements. Compensation is a mathematical process that deals with this problem by removing a percentage of the total signal from each detector.

This percentage corresponds to the amount of spillover signal that is contributed to any given detector by all the other fluorophores being used in the experiment. The compensation calculation relies on the fundamental concept that the amount of spillover of a fluorophore (e.g. fluorophore A) into a detector (e.g. fluorophore B) is defined by the ratio of A’s signal in B’s detector to A’s signal in its own detector. This relationship between two detectors, called spillover coefficient, defines the spillover regardless of the amount of dye, so it can be used correctly for the spectral overlap in a typical experimental setting in which the amounts of dye can vary widely between and within samples.

Fluorescence Minus One

Experimental samples are meaningless if you can’t easily establish the positive from negative population While this may be easy for some major phenotyping markers, it becomes more complex if you are analyzing rare events or determining the positivity of emergent targets, such as activation markers.

How can you convince reviewers that you didn’t make an error and placed your gate in the proper place? How are you going to account for the data spread that occurs with compensation? In any multicolor flow cytometry experiment, the answer to your gating troubles is to use fluorescence minus one controls. FMO controls are samples that contain all the antibodies you are testing in your experimental samples – minus one of them.

When analyzing the excluded parameter in an FMO control, you give yourself a strong negative control to work with. It’s a strong negative control because the left out marker in the FMO control allows you to take into account how the other stains in your panel affect the left out parameter. FMO controls are required for accurately discriminating positive versus negative signals, high versus low (or variable) antigen expression levels, and more. Even simple 2- or 3-color experiments reveal the need for FMO controls when drawing gates.

Reagent controls – titration and isoclonal.

Reagent control methods include titration and isoclonal controls. In your experiments, it is important to validate the amount of antibody used for staining. If too much antibody is used, there will be an increase in non-specific binding, which reduces sensitivity. Yet too little antibody, and the cells will not be saturated – this too results in reduced sensitivity.

The best way to determine the optimal antibody concentration is to perform a titration experiment. In a titration experiment, you vary the amount of antibody used in staining while holding other variables—incubation time, temperature, and cell concentration—constant. After acquiring the data, calculate the staining index for each concentration. An example of a titration experiment is shown below.

The isoclonal control was originally published to demonstrate that the cells of interest were not binding the fluorochrome on the antibodies, as has been shown for CD64. The isoclonal control is a great way to show that you have specific binding, as shown below.

Gating

Identifying the target cells of an experiment is key to evaluating the biological hypothesis. Populations of cells that do not meet established criteria must be removed. Using the data-reduction method known as “gating,” the researcher acts as a kind of gatekeeper, controlling what can pass based on the controls designed for a specific experiment. There are 3 major controls that qualify as gating methods, described here in summary: First, there is the fluorescence minus one control (FMO). As we already discussed,  this control is designed to identify the effects of spectral overlap of fluorochromes into the channel of interest. 

Second, there are internal negative controls (INC): cells in the staining sample that do not express the marker of interest. Unlike the FMO control, where one reagent is left out, the INC is exposed to all the markers, but biologically, it does not express the marker of interest. The INC can help identify and address proper gating when there is non-specific binding of the antibody. 

The use of the isotype control remains controversial and is not recommended as a gating control. Based on the assumptions that must be made for this control, it should be relied on to determine positivity. 

The third option in gating is the unstimulated control, which is useful for stimulation experiments. This gating method relies on the biology of the system to assist in setting the proper gate. It takes into account the background binding of the target antibody since the unstimulated cells should not be expressing the target. 

In conclusion, to improve reproducibility, you must examine and understand the many controls available to a researcher. Minimize the effects of confounding variables in your experiment by using appropriate control methods to identify changes caused by the independent variable and exercise any confounding variables that may attempt to haunt your experiment.

To learn more about important control measures for your flow cytometry lab, and to get access to all of our advanced materials including 20 training videos, presentations, workbooks, and private group membership, get on the Flow Cytometry Mastery Class wait list.

Join Expert Cytometry's Mastery Class
Tim Bushnell, PhD
Tim Bushnell, PhD

Tim Bushnell holds a PhD in Biology from the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. He is a co-founder of—and didactic mind behind—ExCyte, the world’s leading flow cytometry training company, which organization boasts a veritable library of in-the-lab resources on sequencing, microscopy, and related topics in the life sciences.

Similar Articles

The 5 Fundamental Methods For Imaging Nucleic Acids

The 5 Fundamental Methods For Imaging Nucleic Acids

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Designing Microscopy Experiments Related To Infectious Diseases And Antivirals

Designing Microscopy Experiments Related To Infectious Diseases And Antivirals

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

My 3-Step Panel Validation Pocket Guide

My 3-Step Panel Validation Pocket Guide

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Easy-To-Forget Flow Fundamentals That Thwart Bad Science

Easy-To-Forget Flow Fundamentals That Thwart Bad Science

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

4 Factors To Improve Flow Cytometry Cell Sorting Speed

4 Factors To Improve Flow Cytometry Cell Sorting Speed

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

5 Techniques For Dramatic Improvements In Reproducibility

5 Techniques For Dramatic Improvements In Reproducibility

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

It’s not easy to improve reproducibility in your experiments. Image manipulation has become a major problem in science, whether intentional or accidental. This has exploded with the advent of digital imaging and software like Photoshop. There are even mobile applications like Instagram filters that can be used for imaging trickery. It should go without saying that image reuse/manipulation represents profound dishonesty in science – a field intended to uphold the most stringent possible standards of truthful inquiry! But what about studies with a sloppy or stunted capacity for reproduction? These, too, plague science and hinder our ability to seamlessly move…

3 Compensation Mistakes That Will Ruin Your Flow Cytometry Experiments

3 Compensation Mistakes That Will Ruin Your Flow Cytometry Experiments

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

Compensation is necessary due to the physics of fluorescence. Basically, compensation is the mathematical process of correcting spectral spillover from a fluorochrome into a secondary detector so that it is possible to identify single positive events in the context of a multidimensional panel. Good compensation requires that your controls tightly adhere to three rules. If the controls don’t meet this criteria, it will lead to faulty compensation resulting in false conclusions and poorly reproducible data. Even among flow cytometry veterans, a strong foundation is occasionally in need of a tune-up. And in a topic as complex as flow cytometry, it’s…

Understanding Reproducibility in Flow Cytometry - It’s the Antibodies!

Understanding Reproducibility in Flow Cytometry - It’s the Antibodies!

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

Reproducibility is key to the scientific method. After the results of a study are published, the community validates the findings and extends them. If the findings are not reproducible, the second step is impossible. With performable experiments increasing in complexity, and the concurrent increase in the cost of equipment and reagents to perform these experiments, it is important to find the best way to maximize the money spent on advancing research. In flow cytometry, there are many places where improvements can be made to increase the consistency and reproducibility of an experiment. The most obvious place is in the instrument,…

Top Technical Training eBooks

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

Learn the best practices and advanced techniques across the diverse fields of microscopy, including instrumentation, experimental setup, image analysis, figure preparation, and more.

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Learn the best practices of flow cytometry experimentation, data analysis, figure preparation, antibody panel design, instrumentation and more.

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Advanced 4-10 Color Compensation, Learn strategies for designing advanced antibody compensation panels and how to use your compensation matrix to analyze your experimental data.