Why Flow Cytometry Fluorescence Compensation Is Critical For Quality Measurements

Written by Tim Bushnell, PhD

Fluorescence compensation is one of the more difficult, understandably confusing, and misunderstood aspects of flow cytometry.

Compensation is almost always necessary when more than four or five colors are measured simultaneously. As such, understanding what compensation is, why it is necessary, and what to expect when using it, are critical for generating useful and high-quality data from flow cytometry experiments.

In order to understand compensation correctly, you need to understand the answers to 3 core questions related to compensation…

1. What is the nature of fluorophores?

The necessity of compensation arises from the nature of fluorophores, the fundamental and cherished tools of flow cytometry.

We often tend to associate a fluorophore with a particular color. For example, we often say that “FITC is ‘green’” and “APC is ‘red.’” While it is true that when FITC is excited it is most likely to emit photons in the “green” range (around 520 nm), it is also true that FITC will emit photons of other wavelengths of colors, from about 480-600 nm. However, the number of “non-green” photons that FITC emits gets lower and lower the farther the wavelength is from the emission maximum of FITC of ~520 nm.

The “spectral promiscuity” of fluorophores is a problem for flow cytometric measurements. A spectral plot, which describes the excitation and emission spectra of a fluorophore, is a powerful tool to understand why.

The plot shown below, reproduced from the BioLegend Spectra Analyzer, illustrates the emission spectra of two commonly used 405 nm excitable fluorophores: Brilliant Violet 510™ and Brilliant Violet 605™. Additionally, the spectral plot also illustrates the wavelength ranges (spectral bands) of bandpass filters that can be used to measure these fluorophores.

Flow cytometer excitable fluorophores

Notice how wide the curves are for both fluorophores and especially how wide the emission profile is for Brilliant Violet 510™.

This fluorophore, although mainly “green,” emits photons of all sorts of colors — from <450 nm all the way up to around 700 nm. That is quite a range! This wide span of emission wavelength quickly becomes a big problem as more and more colors are used.

The spectral detection range used in flow cytometry is about 370 nm up to about 800 nm, and there are only so many ways that this distance can be partitioned into spectral regions.

Because of this, spectral overlap, or the presence of one fluorophore in another’s detector, is inevitable in multicolor cytometry.

Specifically, in an experiment where two fluorophores are used, A and B, and two detectors designated to measure those fluorophores, DA and DB are used, A will be measured not only in DA but a portion of A’s fluorescence will also be measured in DB. Likewise, depending on the filter and the molecule, B may be measured in both DB and DA.

As illustrated in the spectral plot above, because of the wide emission profile of Brilliant Violet 510™, it will be detected in a bandpass filter about 85 nm away.

2. What is the spillover coefficient?

This reality of fluorophores would render data from multicolor experiments useless if something weren’t done to deal with it. That thing is compensation, which is a mathematical operation that accounts for and subtracts the spillover signal (i.e. the signal from other fluorophores) in every detector used in any flow cytometry experiment.

This process can be performed either manually or automatically, the automatic route being more preferable and accurate, especially as more and more colors are used.

While the comprehensive mathematical basis of compensation is beyond the scope of this article, taking the time to understand how it works from a high-level leads us one big step away from the “black box” model of interacting with a cytometer.

As always, the more transparent the box, the better the cytometry and the better the science.

The basic principle of compensation relies on one critical concept…

The amount of spillover signal in a secondary detector is always proportional to the amount of signal in the primary detector, regardless of the amount of fluorophore present.

In other words, in a two-color experiment utilizing fluorophore A and fluorophore B, if 20% of A’s emission spectrum is measured in B’s detector, we can always calculate the true signal of B in its detector, no matter how much of each dye is present, by co-opting the constant proportionality between A’s signal in B’s detector and A’s signal in A’s detector; the signal in from A in B’s detector is always 20% of A’s signal in its own detector.

To calculate this proportionality coefficient, properly called the spillover coefficient, we use single-color controls that contain only one fluorophore. By doing this, we can then measure the signal from this fluorophore, independently of any other fluorophore, in all detectors which facilitates calculation of the spillover coefficient.

Let’s look at the math to parse this out a bit. Stick with us here, even if math stirs up some trepidation.

The explanation below is from a report in a Current Protocols of Cytometry and it illustrates two-way compensation between two detectors, and assumes that we are using two fluorophores: fluorophore A and fluorophore B. While this is an atypically simple explanation, the principles described below carry through to the broader method compensation of any number of parameters.

We will use a few abbreviations, defined as follows:

AFA = signal from fluorophore A in its own detector (detector A)
AFB= signal from fluorophore A in B’s detector
BFB= signal from B in its own detector
BFA= signal from B in A’s detector
DA = total measured signal in A’s primary detector
DB = total measured signal in B’s primary detector

Therefore, the measured signals in each detector are:

DA = AFA+BFA
DB = AFB+BFB

The spillover coefficients for A’s and B’s detectors, S, can be defined as follows:

ASB = AFB / AFA
BSA = BFA / BFB

In order to actually calculate the spillover coefficients, we need to measure signal from each fluorophore independently and thus need single color controls. The total signals, from a control containing only fluorophore A, in each detector is:

DA = AFA+BFA = AFA+ 0 = AFA
DB = AFB+BFB = AFB+ 0 = AFB

Therefore, for A’s single-stained control:

ASB = AFB / AFA = DB /DA

Similarly, for B’s single-stained control:

BSA = BFA / BFB = DA /DB

Once the proportionality constants are defined, the “real” fluorescence in any detector in a fully-stained sample can be easily calculated by rearranging equations. Easy!

In the fully-stained sample:

DA = AFA+BFA = AFA + (BFB x BSA)
(BFB x BSA is obtained by rearranging the spillover coefficient for BSA)
DB = AFB+BFB = (AFA x ASB) + BFB
(AFA x ASB is obtained by rearranging the spillover coefficient for ASB)

All we need to do now is to do some crafty algebra to obtain the actual amount of A (AFA) in detector A and the actual amount of B (BFB) in detector B.

3. What is a compensation matrix?

When only two colors are used, the math is simple — it’s just algebra.

However, there is a way of calculating compensation for any number of parameters, which applies to more real-life cytometry experiments when many colors and detectors are used.

This method is an extension of the equations described above and uses linear algebra to generate a spillover coefficient matrix for all parameters being used to measure fluorescence in the experiment.

The math used in this case requires that the spillover coefficient matrix be inverted, which ends up as the compensation matrix.

The difference between the spillover coefficient versus the compensation matrix have been described in the same Current Protocols of Cytometry report:

“The spillover coefficients are closely related to the spectrum of a fluorophore: they convey the amount of a fluorophore’s emission is each of the detectors. The compensation matrix tells how much of each detector’s value must be subtracted in order to determine the final calculated true fluorescence.”

Because the compensation matrix is more relevant to cytometry data — it tells us what to subtract from the detector in order to see the true fluorescence from its primary fluorophore — it is what is displayed in cytometry acquisition and analysis software.

You won’t ever have to perform these calculations yourself as, whether you are compensating manually or automatically, all of these calculations are performed by the computer. That being said, the cytometrist’s job is far from complete.

The basics of compensation as defined here provide foundational understanding of flow cytometry compensation. What it is, why it’s necessary, and what to expect make up the introduction to this series. Stay tuned for the next article on compensation for a deeper look into controls, the nuances of compensated data, and some mythbusting.

To learn more about why flow cytometry fluorescence compensation is critical for quality measurements and to get access to all of our advanced materials including 20 training videos, presentations, workbooks, and private group membership, get on the Flow Cytometry Mastery Class wait list.

Join Expert Cytometry's Mastery Class
Tim Bushnell, PhD
Tim Bushnell, PhD

Tim Bushnell holds a PhD in Biology from the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. He is a co-founder of—and didactic mind behind—ExCyte, the world’s leading flow cytometry training company, which organization boasts a veritable library of in-the-lab resources on sequencing, microscopy, and related topics in the life sciences.

Similar Articles

Tools to Improve Your Panel Design – Determining Antigen Density

Tools to Improve Your Panel Design – Determining Antigen Density

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

When a researcher chooses to use flow cytometry to answer a scientific question, they first have to build a polychromatic panel that will take advantage of the power of the technology and experimental design. When we set up to use flow cytometry to answer a scientific question, we have to design a polychromatic panel that will allow us to identify the cells of interest – the target of the research.  To identify these cells, we need to build a panel that takes advantage of the relative brightness of the fluorochromes, the expression level of the different proteins on the cell,…

This Is How Full Spectrum Cytometry Works

This Is How Full Spectrum Cytometry Works

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

My Proven 5-Point Fast Track To A Career In Flow

My Proven 5-Point Fast Track To A Career In Flow

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Up Your Stain Game With These 7 Non-Fluorescent Histology Dyes

Up Your Stain Game With These 7 Non-Fluorescent Histology Dyes

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

3 Ways Flow Cytometry Can Be Used To Research Bacteria

3 Ways Flow Cytometry Can Be Used To Research Bacteria

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Discover The Myriad Applications Of Beads In Flow Cytometry

Discover The Myriad Applications Of Beads In Flow Cytometry

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

What is the single-most important feature of a flow cytometry experiment? Arguably, it’s the stained cells that gather data about biological processes of interest. However, a flow cytometer can measure cell-like particles as well as cells, which opens the realm of cytometry to the use of microspheres. Most researchers are familiar with the 4-Cs that beads can be used for: Control, Calibration, Compensation, and Counting. Beyond the 4-Cs, many are familiar with the multiplex bead assays for measuring analytes. Today, we will take a look beyond these well-known uses and discover the myriad applications of the “Mighty Microspheres.”

Mass Cytometry Revolves Around These 5 Things

Mass Cytometry Revolves Around These 5 Things

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

Because mass cytometry allows users to characterize masses so effectively, data can be normalized much more efficiently than what traditional fluorescent flow will permit. If there is no working CyTof at your institution, you can still partner with CyTof-friendly research institutions that have the technology on hand. And because the samples are fixed, you can ship them overnight. This way, they will be analyzed for you. Today’s article will summarize the functionality of mass cytometry technology. This tech has been commercialized largely by Fluidigm in the CyTof systems. There are 5 key points to cover, or takeaways, that cytometrists should…

3 Ways To Improve Flow Cytometry Troubleshooting

3 Ways To Improve Flow Cytometry Troubleshooting

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

A lot of the troubleshooting is focused on fluidics issues. If you sit down and think about your workflow, and how you might want to add a couple of little tweaks here and there which will ultimately help you improve the quality of your data as well as aid you in identifying issues before they become problems your troubleshooting will be much smoother. Consider these three things, what do you before you start collecting data, ensure you have appropriate plots of time vs fluorescence for each of the lasers your using and apply appropriate gating procedures.

Top Technical Training eBooks

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

Learn the best practices and advanced techniques across the diverse fields of microscopy, including instrumentation, experimental setup, image analysis, figure preparation, and more.

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Learn the best practices of flow cytometry experimentation, data analysis, figure preparation, antibody panel design, instrumentation and more.

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Advanced 4-10 Color Compensation, Learn strategies for designing advanced antibody compensation panels and how to use your compensation matrix to analyze your experimental data.