3 Action Steps You Can Take Right Now To Improve Your Flow Cytometry Reproducibility

Reproducibility is a key issue in science.

Massive amounts of time and money are wasted when the results of experiments are not reproducible.

For example, I was called into a lab to look at their data because they had spent thousands of dollars sorting precious human samples and were now doing genomics analysis with the isolated cells.

Unfortunately, the results of the genomics analysis made no sense based on the sorted populations. The lab was working backward through every step of the process to try to identify what might have happened and if the experiments were salvageable.

As I reviewed the sorting process, one of the striking factors was that the quality control of the cell sorting experiments was very, very poor. In fact, it was non-existent.

So whoever was running their sorter was not performing quality control on the instrument, so the sorting results were all over the place. Voltages were changed dramatically for each experiment, and the separation of the target cells ranged from barley differentiated to well separated. The compensation controls told another story about the problems with these sorting experiments.

In the end, this lab wasted tens of thousands of dollars, countless man-hours, and precious lost samples because there was not a focus on quality control and best practices.

Reproducibility is a state of mind.

It’s not one simple thing that you do that will make all your data more reproducible, it a shift in the way one thinks about and perform experiments.

With the emphasis on rigor and reproducibility in science, it’s very important that researchers start putting into place everything they can do to help improve the quality and reproducibility of their data.

Here are 3 action steps that can be taken to enhance experimental reproducibility…

1. Evaluate your quality control processes to improve reproducibility.

Quality control is an important component of reproducibility.

That includes monitoring the quality control of the instrument by making sure that quality control metrics are being run on a daily basis.

You, the end user, have a right to ask to look at that data.

Don’t be afraid to go up to whoever’s running the machine and say, “Hey, how’s the quality of the machine? “Can I look at the QC data, and see how it’s going?”

Let them talk to you about it so you understand what it means so that you can get a better feel for what’s going on with your instrument.

Figure 1: Quality control tracking using beads.

You don’t want to sit down at a machine that is not working properly and be unaware of the systems limitations.

Your data will end up looking poor or worse – you might make erroneous conclusions because the machine wasn’t performing properly.

Quality control is done to make sure the machine performs consistently on a day-to-day basis.

That means that you, as the end user, should also be thinking about quality control of your experiments, it is not just the job of the core facility.

At a minimum, researchers can include a bead tandard as a way of monitoring quality control before running the experiment.

2. Develop the assay completely before performing the assay.

When sitting down and to develop an assay, it’s important to work through the whole process.

The first part of that process is understanding what the biology is and what the experiment is trying to prove.

Next, sketch out the proposed primary analysis – what will the gating strategy look like, and what data will be extracted for secondary analysis. If the experiment is a cell sorting experiment, understand what the downstream application that cells will be used for is, and the limitations of that assay.

It is also important to decide what statistical analysis will be performed and calculate the power of the experiment to determine how many samples will be needed. These steps will go a long way to prevent p-hacking and prevent HARKing.

With those steps completed, the next step is experimental design. That includes what instrument will be used, what antigens will be needed and build an initial panel. Reviewing the diagrams for analysis that were drawn above can help identify what are the critical targets. Those should be paired with bright fluorochromes and in channels that have a low error that will allow for a more sensitive measurement. With this in place, the next steps include testing the reagents (titration and voltage optimization). From there, comes the optimization process, where the best conditions for the assay are determined.

Figure 2: Error contribution based on detector and fluorochromes.

After optimization comes validation of the assay. This includes characterization of the necessary controls that will ensure identification of the target populations, demonstrate the stability of the assay, the variation within the staining process and the like. Once the assay is validated, the process is locked down, using Standard Operating Procedures.

3. Ensure you have quality SOPs in place.

For those who are working in a regulated environment, the SOP is part of the daily routine. For others, the idea of a protocol is more common. The biggest difference between the two documents is the level of document control and the expectation of how close the document is followed. With SOPs, they must be followed exactly, and deviations have to be noted and signed. SOPs are not changed without significant discussion and demonstration of the need for change. All details about the reagents are noted, serial numbers of equipment, lot numbers of reagents and more. The exacting SOP ensures that everyone performs the experiment the same way.

A protocol, on the other hand, lists the general steps to follow. It is often changed on the fly, based on the needs of the experiment at the time. It lists recommended controls, but not all may be necessary for the specific assay. The level of detail about reagents and more are not expected.

For those performing a longitudinal study or for a long period of time, developing and implementing an SOP will improve the rigor of the experiment.

An added benefit of the SOP is that it can be used to train additional researchers to assist in the experiment, as they will know exactly what the steps are and how to perform them.

Reproducibility is the name of the game, take a few minutes to think about how you can change your activities and your research workflow to increase the quality and consistency of your data. A few action steps that you can take right now to improve your data’s reproducibility is to Evaluate your quality control processes, develop the assay completely before performing the assay, and ensure you have quality SOPs in place. Taking those few simple steps will protect you from the problems associated with non-reproducible data.

To learn more about the 3 Action Steps You Can Take Right Now To Improve Your Flow Cytometry Reproducibility, and to get access to all of our advanced materials including 20 training videos, presentations, workbooks, and private group membership, get on the Flow Cytometry Mastery Class wait list.

Join Expert Cytometry's Mastery Class
Tim Bushnell, PhD
Tim Bushnell, PhD

Tim Bushnell holds a PhD in Biology from the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. He is a co-founder of—and didactic mind behind—ExCyte, the world’s leading flow cytometry training company, which organization boasts a veritable library of in-the-lab resources on sequencing, microscopy, and related topics in the life sciences.

Similar Articles

How To Profile DNA And RNA Expression Using Next Generation Sequencing

How To Profile DNA And RNA Expression Using Next Generation Sequencing

By: Deepak Kumar, PhD

Why is Next Generation Sequencing so powerful to explore and answer both clinical and research questions. With the ability to sequence whole genomes, identifying novel changes between individuals, to exploring what RNA sequences are being expressed, or to examine DNA modifications and protein-DNA interactions occurring that can help researchers better understand the complex regulation of transcription. This, in turn, allows them to characterize changes during different disease states, which can suggest a way to treat said disease.  Over the next two blogs, I will highlight these different methods along with illustrating how these can help clinical diagnostics as well as…

Optimizing Flow Cytometry Experiments - Part 2         How To Block Samples (Sample Blocking)

Optimizing Flow Cytometry Experiments - Part 2 How To Block Samples (Sample Blocking)

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

In my previous blog on  experimental optimization, we discussed the idea of identifying the best antibody concentration for staining the cells. We did this through a process called titration, which  focuses on finding the best signal-to-noise ratio at the lowest antibody concentration. In this blog we will deal with sample blocking As a reminder, there are two other major binding concerns with antibodies. The first is the specific binding of the Fc fragment of the antibody to the Fc Receptor expressed on some cells. This protein is critical for the process of destroying microbes or other cells that have been…

What Is Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) And How Is It Used In Drug Development

What Is Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) And How Is It Used In Drug Development

By: Deepak Kumar, PhD

NGS methodologies have been used to produce high-throughput sequence data. These data with appropriate computational analyses facilitate variant identification and prove to be extremely valuable in pharmaceutical industries and clinical practice for developing drug molecules inhibiting disease progression. Thus, by providing a comprehensive profile of an individual’s variome — particularly that of clinical relevance consisting of pathogenic variants — NGS helps in determining new disease genes. The information thus obtained on genetic variations and the target disease genes can be used by the Pharma companies to develop drugs impeding these variants and their disease-causing effect. However simple this may allude…

How To Determine The Optimal Antibody Concentration For Your Flow Cytometry Experiment (Part 1 of 6)

How To Determine The Optimal Antibody Concentration For Your Flow Cytometry Experiment (Part 1 of 6)

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

Over the next series of blog posts, we will explore the different aspects of optimizing a polychromatic flow cytometry panel. These steps range from figuring out the best voltage to use, which controls are critical for data interpretation, what quality control tools can be integrated into the assay; how to block cells, and more. This blog will focus on determining the optimal antibody concentration.  As a reminder about the antibody structure, a schematic of an antibody is shown below.  Figure 1: Schematic of an antibody. Figure from Wikipedia. The antibody is composed of two heavy chains and two light chains that…

Brightness Is In The Eye Of The Detector - What To Consider When Designing Your Panel

Brightness Is In The Eye Of The Detector - What To Consider When Designing Your Panel

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

The heart and soul of the flow cytometry experiment is the ‘panel.’ The unique combinations of antibodies, antigens, fluorochromes, and other reagents are central to identifying the cells of interest and extracting the data necessary to answer the question at hand. Designing the right panel for flow cytometry is essential for detecting different modalities. The more parameters that can be interrogated will yield more information about the target cells. Current instruments can measure as many as 40 different parameters simultaneously. This is exciting, as it allows for more complex questions to be studied. Panel design is also valuable for precious samples,…

The 5 Fundamental Methods For Imaging Nucleic Acids

The 5 Fundamental Methods For Imaging Nucleic Acids

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

Avoid Flow Cytometry Faux Pas: How To Set Voltage The Right Way

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Designing Microscopy Experiments Related To Infectious Diseases And Antivirals

Designing Microscopy Experiments Related To Infectious Diseases And Antivirals

By: Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

My 3-Step Panel Validation Pocket Guide

My 3-Step Panel Validation Pocket Guide

By: Tim Bushnell, PhD

There are 4 major ways to sort cells. The first way can use magnetic beads coupled to antibodies and pass the cells through a magnetic field. The labeled cells will stick, and the unlabeled cells will remain in the supernatant. The second way is to use some sort of mechanical force like a flapper or air stream that separates the target cells from the bulk population. The third way is the recently introduced microfluidics sorter, which uses microfluidics channels to isolate the target cells. The last method, which is the most common––based on Fuwyler’s work––is the electrostatic cell sorter. This…

Top Technical Training eBooks

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Get the Advanced Microscopy eBook

Heather Brown-Harding, PhD

Learn the best practices and advanced techniques across the diverse fields of microscopy, including instrumentation, experimental setup, image analysis, figure preparation, and more.

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Get The Free Modern Flow Cytometry eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Learn the best practices of flow cytometry experimentation, data analysis, figure preparation, antibody panel design, instrumentation and more.

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Get The Free 4-10 Compensation eBook

Tim Bushnell, PhD

Advanced 4-10 Color Compensation, Learn strategies for designing advanced antibody compensation panels and how to use your compensation matrix to analyze your experimental data.